| Literature / Poetry / General Poetry / Free Verse | ©2011-2013 ~xthe-eleanorx |
The Journal Portal
Browse Journals |
Polls |
deviantART [dee·vee·un'nt·ART]
Keep in Touch!
|
Deviousness |
1. No, the separations do not make the poem too choppy, I think the separation of the lines works just fine.
2. No, it doesn't matter, I think it's great that "A dreamer" has its own line, it places more emphasis on that line, which I think works very well for this poem.
3. I like the ending. In fact, I love it! It made me smile, I think it's great!
4. Ah, yeah... Don't know, titles are difficult... And I have no idea if you've already changed it, it's been a while since you submitted this, I'm pretty late in commenting.
5. I guess I began this comment with this part. I just really love it, it's wonderful, short and magical. I love the "He is a reader" stanza, love the imagery! This is a really wonderful piece!
(I actually still haven't managed to find a decent title, I suppose I gave up in the process.
A dreamer
Who hums to himself while his eyes float across the page. " - I love the feeling you get about the character from these lines; you just picture him sitting in a chair in front of a fire reading to himself. lol. At least that's what I got from it.
1. There's something about the word choice that makes the choppy lines feel right. I wouldn't change a thing.
2. I thought the third line here was intentional, so I would have to say no, it does not affect the rhythm. In my opinion, it actually adds to the flow of the piece.
3. The ending was my favorite part! What are you talking about? lol. I thought it was such a clever way to end the poem and leave the reader wondering who you are, and who he is; and you almost feel a little infatuated yourself.
4.
Love this
s'il vous plait is a French term meaning 'if you please'--it's the SVP in RSVP.
Now that I understand the question: I think something like "My Man Poet" would be cute and, and since you put such a stain on it, I think it would make the reader feel like it's more of an "admiring infatuation" instead of a homosexual infatuation; which is what I got when I first read the title and poem combined. Just a suggestion though
No, I don't think it does make the poem choppy at all. I think it works; you've started each stanza with the same 'He is...' which helps to link them all together, and it is clear that each of the thoughts follow on from each other and are about the same person. I also think that the simplicity and shortness of this poem helps to emphasise the extent of the infatuation the speaker has with this person. Almost as if they know so little about him, but it doesn't matter...
2. In the third stanza 'a dreamer' is given a separate line making this stanza three lines rather than two. Does this...matter?
Not at all.
3. I am on the fence about the ending, what about you?
I like the to-the-point bluntness of the ending after the descriptions and thoughts, but I'm not sure if it isn't a little clumsy... on second thought, I do like it. It sounds good if read aloud.
I'm afraid I really can't help with titles; my own are bad enough and I wouldn't inflict that upon anyone.
My thoughts are that I love this. I also didn't think of homosexuality when I read the original first line, rather of Oscar Wilde himself with all his wit and irony. Saying that, I like the addition of the word 'inspired'.